
For my On/Off experiment I decided to work on the cold frame (greenhouse for starting seeds) that I am building for my balcony. It was interesting reflecting on the many differences between woodworking and digital design. The biggest difference to me is in the amount of and interaction between sensory phenomena. Something about computer screens holds perception to the actions that happen on the screen. This is shown by saying such as “glued to a screen”. Whereas when working in a woodshop perception is always shared between the tools that you are using and the wood that you are handling. For example when using a band saw you are both watching the blade and moving the wood. I believe that multiple phenomena lead to a different type of engagement and maybe a more democratic sense of being? Another difference between woodworking and digital work is that woodworking is grounded in community space whereas digital work is perceived as separate from lived geography. When working digitally I am often actually alone or I perceive myself as alone because of how computer screens hold perception. Whereas the woodshop is an inherently social space. I got a lot less done on my cold frame then I expected because I ended up having a lengthy conversation about equity and community engagement in education.
In higher education, it seems that social and material spaces are being pushed to the margins by third party software such as Canvas and Zoom. I'm interested in how this has happened. Maybe digital spaces better reflect the corporate and socially disengaged aesthetics of 21st century academia? If higher education becomes a station for students to import data to third party software and for teachers to output grades what will happen to spaces like a woodshop? Maybe they will become a social underground where community experiences go unnoticed by a mostly remote school? Maybe that's too utopian, maybe they will be consumed by the bureaucracy of 21st century higher ED and become selling points in a brochure that can only be accessed by students with extremely specific and restrictive clearances and permissions?
I hadn't considered as deeply the social aspect of spaces like woodshops versus the isolation often felt in digital environments. Your reflection brings to light the invaluable role that shared physical spaces play in fostering community and dialogue, something that's increasingly rare in our digital workflows. I really love the insight that emphasizes the need for balance between digital convenience and physical community.
ReplyDelete