Making Connections 2/21



Angry rant…:

I was honestly very surprised by New Opportunities for Interest Driven Arts Learning in a Digital Age. To me an argument that praises a tool of technology and then immediately provides a name or link to buy that thing seems suspicious. I was also surprised that their argument for screen technologies as democratizing was predicated on artists who do not use screen technologies only using high art materials. As we all know, fine artists have been incorporating “low art” material into their work for at least the last 100 years. I am also curious about where the funding for writing like this comes from? If this was written in any other field I assume the blatant advertising would be taken as corruption. Without any critical analysis of screen technology it is hard to read it as a serious argument and not as a shopping list for video games and gadgets. The products are positioned in relation to other ideas to give them legitimacy without developing an argument for why they are a more useful tool by using the associative word “can” . For example in the section on photography which starts with advertising photo editing software the author says “photography can be a tool for social justice” this doesn't produce a reason for why photography is useful for social justice instead it relates photographic technology to the aesthetic of social justice. I do not feel that this writing can be legitimate until it can be compared to something critical. I am excited to find out more about critical scholarship on ED tech, New Media, and STEAM?

Connection to video:
One thing that I did agree with in the article was that it is important to use digital technologies to connect people back to material space. The article used the example of a photography club. I think making videos in groups is an exciting way to connect groups of people. However what is important about this is group relation and aesthetic perception. Video technology does affect these things however I believe it still remains secondary to human and cultural goals. To say that it is a lesson about video technology makes the subject (student) a vessel for the for-profit production and consumption of video technology. Whereas to say the lesson is about students taking a video of something meaningful positions the for-profit technology as a conduit between the subject and meaning. This also holds danger in how a for-profit business mediates perception of meaning. However the subject (student) still uses the tool instead of acting in service of the tools production and consumption.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

2D Design 3/27

Video 2/21

Digital Collage 1/24